Skip to content

Blog

The Gray Area: When Is Work Essential and When Is It Not?

Day to day and hour to hour, the rules keep changing—what was deemed essential, and therefore exempt from work-at-home requirements under Executive Order 202.6 yesterday may not be considered essential today.  As of yesterday, State guidance permitted all construction work to proceed under the Executive Order. This morning, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo declared that all construction work that is not “truly” essential must shut down or risk fines of up to $10,000 per violation, and the guidance was updated to reflect this change.  This most recent declaration, like many of the others issued over the past two weeks, has left many questioning what it means for their work and their projects.

What started as a blanket exemption for construction has now narrowed to those projects deemed “essential,” which the State says includes “roads, bridges, transit facilities, utilities, hospitals or health care facilities, affordable housing, and homeless shelters.”  Also permitted to continue is work on non-essential projects that is necessary to protect health and safety of occupants, as well as work that would be unsafe if it remained incomplete (although that work may continue only to the point where it is deemed safe to shut down).  That, for now, is the extent of the guidance from the State.  Questions remain concerning non-essential work that skirts the borderline between work that is necessary to protect health and safety of building occupants, or that which would be unsafe if allowed to remain incomplete, and that which is not.  Questions also remain concerning work that is not the subject of its own exemption, but may fall under the penumbra of one or more other exemptions.  Whether that work may continue will depend entirely on how liberally the exemptions will be interpreted.

Environmental remediation work is one example.  Until this morning, a large percentage of that work may have qualified as services that support construction, but these services are, for the most part, no longer covered by the exemption.  Some remediation work may fairly be described as necessary to protect health and safety of building occupants, or to avoid otherwise unsafe conditions if the work were allowed to remain incomplete.  There are scores of sites, however, where contamination has existed for decades; while the remediation of those sites would undoubtedly benefit public health and safety, is that benefit so essential that it should not be delayed?  For work where there is a logical argument to extend the exemption, an assessment is going to have to be made as to whether the risk of penalties outweighs the costs of delay.  Whether or not work is covered by the exemption may well become a point of dispute between developers and contractors unwilling to take such a risk, or whose workers object to reporting to a site.

Environmental Insurance Coverage and COVID-19

As many businesses face closures pursuant to governmental directives designed to combat the spread of COVID-19, such closures may trigger claims under property and comprehensive...

Read More

Essential Services Exempt From Covid-19 Workplace “Pause”

Governor Cuomo’s “New York on Pause” Executive Order No. 202.8 (requiring all workplaces to maintain a 0% in-person workforce) exempts “Essential Services.”  At the direction...

Read More

Coronavirus and Construction Project Delays

The rapid spread of the novel coronavirus is, at least within the last century, an unprecedented event.  Few segments of the economy have been spared...

Read More

NYSERDA Requests PSC Authorization to Procure at Least 1,000 MW of Offshore Wind Capacity in 2020

On January 28, 2020, the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (“NYSERDA”) submitted a petition to the New York State Public Service Commission...

Read More

Meet Katie Ghilain, Who Was Recently Promoted From Associate to Principal at SPR

Katie has always had a passion for the environment. Throughout her studies at Vassar College and NYU Law, she focused on how her varied areas...

Read More